Why High-Achieving Women Overthink (And Why It’s Not a Mindset Problem)

I want to be really clear about something, because this gets misunderstood all the time: Overthinking is not you trying to listen to your intuition more deeply or figure out what you actually want to do. Overthinking is a trauma response. And I say that with a lot of compassion, because I have struggled with overthinking myself.

(Prefer the voice notes version of this post? Give this podcast episode a listen. ↓)

A lot of high-achieving women label themselves as chronic overthinkers. And I’m not just talking about overthinking when things aren’t going the way you want them to in your relationship. I’m talking about overthinking that affects how you show up at work, how you make decisions, how you lead, how you speak, and how you move through your life. 

Often, when you’re overthinking, perfectionism is looped in there as well. They go hand in hand. You’re trying to make something perfect, to get it right, to avoid making a mistake. And because you end up spiraling and overthinking, you end up procrastinating. You get stuck in decision paralysis, you don’t move, and then when nothing changes, you feel lost and frustrated with yourself.

But here’s the golden nugget... Overthinking didn’t come from nowhere; it was designed to keep you safe.

Any trauma response is about safety. This isn’t you being broken or failing. It’s your nervous system doing what it learned to do. When you were younger—and this might have been as a child, a teenager, or even a young adult—overthinking helped you survive. Maybe you learned to watch what you said, when you spoke, and how you asked for your needs to be met. Maybe you learned to overthink your next move so you didn’t upset someone, so you didn’t get blamed, so you didn’t become the punching bag. Overthinking helped you get more love, or at the very least less pain.

And I also want to say this, because it matters: trauma doesn’t only come from childhood. Overthinking doesn’t always come from when you were five, ten, or fifteen. Trauma can be created later in life. I see this all the time with my clients—high-level executives, founders, people with visibility, people online, people in leadership roles. One situation at work, one reputational threat, or one experience of being misunderstood, criticised, or put into fight-or-flight can be enough for your system to say, “Right, we’re not letting that happen again.” (Especially after the rise of the cancel culture era circa 2020.)

So, again, you start to overthink. You scan, you anticipate, and you hold back. You become afraid of being seen, of speaking your truth, of saying the wrong thing—or even saying something that isn’t wrong, but might be misinterpreted. This happens a lot in corporate environments, online, and in business. And suddenly you’re not trusting yourself anymore.

What I really want you to hear is this: Your overwhelm is a safety mechanism. When you’re overthinking, you can actually feel it in your body. 

The tension, the tightening, the fear, and the racing mind... those sensations tell you this is trauma. And as I speak to all the time, trauma lives in the body, which is why mindset work alone only gets you so far. Most of the signals in your system are sent from your body to your brain. You need body-based work to truly shift this.

But the very first step is awareness. When you notice yourself spiralling, ask yourself: What am I actually afraid will happen? Not the surface fear, the real one:

• Losing your job
• Being judged
• Being cancelled
• Being seen as a failure
• Losing safety, respect, or belonging

So often, overthinking is just catastrophising a future that hasn’t happened yet.

This is why I often come back to this question when I'm starting to overthink about something I'm about to say:

If I had a gun to my head, would I still say this? Would I still say the thing I want to say? Would I still stand by this belief, this boundary, this truth?

If the answer is yes, you’re anchored. You trust yourself. You’re speaking from integrity. If the answer is no, then you’re likely people-pleasing or seeking approval. You’re not actually standing behind what you’re saying.

This shows up so clearly in relationships as well. You say something honest to your partner, he gets defensive, and then you back down. Later, you regret saying anything at all, and you feel guilty about the whole situation. And if I asked you, “Would you say that again?”, and the answer is no—not because it was unkind, but because you don’t trust yourself to hold your ground—that tells me there’s dysregulation there. There’s fear of abandonment, fear of not being enough, and fear of losing love.

Being in your feminine energy is not about being passive.

A woman who is anchored in her feminine is not silent. She speaks her truth because she has self-respect, and that self-respect is what creates polarity, safety, and mutual respect in a relationship.

The same pattern shows up when it comes to trusting your intuition in life and business. 

• Overthinking a move you know you’re being called towards
• Overthinking visibility
• Overthinking success
• Overthinking expansion

What are you actually afraid will happen if you trust yourself? You're afraid of being judged; outgrowing people; or being seen as too much, too successful, or too intimidating. So you dim your light to stay safe.

Overthinking is trying to protect you.

And once you see that, you can stop shaming yourself for it and start addressing what it actually needs: nervous system regulation, safety in your body, and trust in yourself. Because when you feel safe internally, you don’t need to overthink. You move, you speak, you decide, and you live in integrity with who you actually are.

If this resonated, it’s not something you can think your way out of. Because, as we've talked about, overthinking lives in the nervous system, so the work has to be somatic. The Immersion is where we do exactly that—regulating the body, creating internal safety, and shifting the patterns that keep you stuck. Join the waitlist now to be the first to know when tickets are open for Paris (July 2026) and Atlanta (September 2026).